A - Excellent
B - Very Good
C - Average
D - Below Average (Needs Improvment)
F - Awful (Failing)
Note: Here is the old system, for reviews posted on SuperPhillip Central prior to February 2015.
Perhaps you've been wondering what each number at the end of a review means. Different sites use different scales, and different numbers mean different things on different sites. Well, let me explain my rating scale for games in a simple fashion.
10 - Masterful
9 - Excellent
8 - Great
7 - Good
6 - Fair
5. Average
4. Flawed
3. Poor
2. Horrible
1. Repulsive
or use the long version...
10 - Virtually perfect with incredibly minor or no discernible flaws.
9 - A must-buy for any gamer. Almost but not quite perfect.
8 - A great game only barred by some minor flaws.
7 - An above average game worth a look to any gamer.
6 - Slightly above average but has many flaws holding it back.
5 - An average game that doesn't do too much for gaming as a whole.
4 - A below average game with bothersome flaws. Would only recommend to fans.
3 - A game filled with too many flaws to recommend to anyone.
3 - A game filled with too many flaws to recommend to anyone.
2 - A horrible game which no gamer should play unless curious.
1 - An abomination to gaming. Will use to make spies talk.
1 - An abomination to gaming. Will use to make spies talk.
Essentially, anything from 5-10 has more positives than negatives even if the game may not have been that incredible for me to play. From 0-4.75, there's more negatives than positives-- that is, if there are any positives at all.
Most of my reviews range from the 6-9.75 range, and that's for a good reason. I usually do enough research to know if I'm going to like a game before purchasing it. For those that I'm unsure of or just want to play something god-awful for once, I rent. The majority of the games I review are ones I've done research on and purchased, though I have been burned multiple times before. Hope that clears up why I don't have too many overly negative reviews. Why waste time playing crappy games? I'm not paid to play them like "gaming journalists".
Currently, my lowest-scored game is Ninjabread Man for the Wii which received a 1.5. I rented that out of morbid curiosity, rest assured. Hope this clears things up to those who weren't aware.